In the vast wilderness of Yellowstone National Park, a 50-square-mile stretch of land has been a topic of intrigue and concern. This area is known as the “Zone of Death.” It is rumored to be a place where one could potentially commit crimes without being held accountable due to an unusual overlap of state and federal jurisdictions.
Brian Kalt, a law professor at Michigan State University, coined the term “Zone of Death” in his 2005 paper published in the Georgetown Law Journal. Kalt described a constitutional loophole that exists within the uninhabited areas of Yellowstone. Although the park stretches across Wyoming, Idaho, and Montana, it falls entirely under the federal jurisdiction of the District of Wyoming. This creates a unique circumstance where the “vicinage clause” of the Sixth Amendment could potentially prevent a fair jury from being formed for crimes committed within the Idaho section of the park.
Per the vicinage clause, the jurors must be from the state and district where the crime was committed. However, there are no residents in this remote area, which makes it impossible to form a jury. This raises the question of whether a fair trial could be conducted and whether a conviction can be secured.
Although the “Zone of Death” loophole may seem appealing in theory, it has not yet been tested in court, and no known crimes have been committed in this area. Legal experts argue that even if the boundaries of this zone are disputed, prosecutors would still likely pursue a case. It is also important to note that the idea of “getting away with murder” in this area is overstated and inaccurate. The federal government can change the district boundaries or apply different legal strategies to ensure justice is served.
The “Zone of Death” concept continues to intrigue legal experts and remains a subject of debate among policymakers. A group of lawmakers from Idaho has suggested that Congress should address this legal loophole to prevent any possible abuse of the law.
The “Zone of Death” is not a lawless land but a legal anomaly. It reminds us of the intricacies of our legal system and the significance of structuring our laws to ensure justice for all, regardless of how remote the location is.
Please be safe while in the woods. You can purchase high-quality, long-range walkie-talkies easily through Amazon.
